
AI-generated illustration; not a photograph of the reported event.
- calendar_today November 19, 2026
Background of the Case
The Alberta government is seeking to temporarily halt a court order requiring the production of documents in the ongoing wrongful dismissal lawsuit filed by Athana Mentzelopoulos, the former CEO of Alberta Health Services (AHS). The request was presented to a judge on Thursday as legal representatives on both sides continue to dispute which documents should be disclosed for the trial.
Claims and Allegations
Athana Mentzelopoulos initiated her wrongful dismissal suit in February 2025. She alleges that her firing was a result of launching investigations into certain contracts and procurement processes within AHS. In its formal statement of defence, AHS responds that Mentzelopoulos was terminated because she failed to fulfill her job duties. It is important to note that none of these claims have been tested or proven in court.
Ongoing Legal Battle Over Records
The legal dispute has largely centered on which records should be disclosed as part of the trial. Previously, a judge ordered both AHS and the Alberta government to hand over specific documents to address “gaps and deficiencies” in the information provided up to that point. The government’s legal team, however, is seeking to pause this order until a formal appeal on the matter can be heard.
Positions of the Government and Plaintiff
Mathieu LaFleche, a lawyer representing the Alberta government, asserted that Mentzelopoulos’s dismissal was conducted “on a ‘without cause’ basis.” LaFleche explained that a key issue for the appeal is how the details of her termination have been interpreted by the court. He argued that the court appeared to assume the defence was making a case for termination due to performance issues, which the government disputes as the actual reason for firing.
Brett Code, representing Mentzelopoulos, challenged the government’s stance and suggested the delay tactics were hampering the process. "This is a disgrace, this process that's being used to delay the production of relevant records," Code told the judge. Code further argued that the government alleged false reasons for Mentzelopoulos’s dismissal and was now refusing to provide documents that could disprove those claims.
Judge’s Considerations and Next Steps
Justice Karan Shaner heard arguments on whether to grant the government’s request for a pause on the court order. LaFleche countered the accusation of introducing delays by noting that all parties, including AHS and Mentzelopoulos’s lawyers, have outstanding summary judgment applications, indicating ongoing action in the case.
Justice Shaner reserved her decision on the application for a temporary hold. The case is scheduled to return to court the following week to consider another potential pause on disclosing further records, specifically related to performance assessments, performance concerns, and any warnings given to Mentzelopoulos during her tenure.
Outlook for Lawsuit Proceedings
The dispute over document disclosure is expected to play a significant role as the wrongful dismissal case progresses. With further hearings scheduled and arguments unresolved regarding transparency and the nature of Mentzelopoulos’s termination, the court will determine what evidence can ultimately be presented as the matter moves forward.
Related coverage
Source: cbc.ca.





